Dedicated to the millions of mothers who go through the special hell of not feeling love for their baby from the moment of birth.
Mothers in our culture expect that loving a baby should happen instantly, like being struck by lightning. As soon as the bundle is delivered, we should be struck by joy. Sure, that would be nice, unfortunately, that’s not how it works for everybody. Just like nursing, while for some mother-baby couples, bonding works fine from the get-go, for an astonishingly large number of mothers, bonding can take weeks, (sometimes months), before the mother can experience the all consuming love she is expecting (and expected) to feel.
What comes next is a time of extreme suffering. This suffering is the result of two cultural distortions:
1. The first distortion: whenever there is a big gap between expectations and reality, our reaction is to assume we are at fault, that there is something terribly wrong with us. We don’t stop to examine the validity of the expectation. Much suffering can be greatly reduced, even eliminated, when we expose the expectations as unrealistic. But chances are nobody told you while you were pregnant that many many many very good mothers go through days, weeks, or months, without feeling any love for their baby. This distorted expectation is a leading cause for postpartum depression. Of course it is.
Let’s think of it like an equation for a minute:
(Hormonal changes) + (Body recovering from pregnancy & labor) + (Huge identity shift) + (Acute sleep deprivation) = Extreme Vulnerability
In the absence of bonding adds this to the mix:
(Something is terribly wrong with me) + (I’m a bad mother)= Self Loathing =I’m Evil
Combine the two and you get
(Extreme Vulnerability) +(I’m Evil) = Suicidal Thoughts
The next “logical” thoughts are: I’m a monster that can’t even love her own baby. I cause everybody I care about nothing but pain, I should just do everybody a favor and get out of the way.
Repeat after me: Just because you feel like a monster doesn’t make you a bad mother. All it means is that you are a mother in pain. With the right help, coping skills, and time, this pain will go away.
When I wallowed in that terrible emotional state, the distorted thoughts felt like undeniable truth. This situation is not only horrid, it is extremely dangerous. For me, it led to an overdose of sleep +anxiety medication. Thank God I woke up, alive if not yet well, at the psych-ward of St.Vincent hospital in NYC. It was the first day of my journey to recovery. My mother wasn’t that lucky. She did not survive her PPD. I choose to believe that she somehow saved me from above. (The rest of my story is here. For the overdose story, scroll all the way down to the confession part.)
Imagine how much pain we could prevent if we educated expectant mothers that while eventually all mothers feel love for their child, there is a full spectrum of normal as to how long it takes before she will be able to experience the love and be consumed by it. We should prepare mothers not only for the potential absence of love, but also for the self-loathing thoughts are part of that territory. We should prepare family members to support mothers through this difficult time. I am so angry that our culture fails to do this. It’s one of my motivators with my endeavor here. It’s what keeps me writing when I just want to hide. I want to change the cultural conversation around Postpartum Mood Disorders because when mothers are made aware of the danger, they can be equipped to withstand the assault of the PPDemons. Lives will be saved.
Deep breaths. Writings about this is very hard for me. For the obvious reasons, but also for this one: I am one of the lucky mamas who were struck by the lightning-bolt of love at the moment of birth. The suicide attempt happened 8 months later. My son had health challenges and was waking up every hour. After much of that I lost my ability to sleep, and with it I lost access to my love for him. The only emotion left was guilt. But having the initial connection must have made it easier to handle the pain. I’m almost sure that if I had to endure the lack of initial bonding, I would have attempted suicide much sooner. Throughout my recovery, especially since I started leading PPD support groups, I see that mothers who struggle to feel love for their newborns are especially at risk. And there is a part of me that feels like I have no right to write about the lack of bonding, because my experience with the absence of love came later. It’s taken me over a week to write this post because of much of soul-searching and inner monster negotiations. I press on, because I know that I have a duty to write this post. I’m not exactly a religious person, but my life’s story makes it easy to believe in God. And as strange as this sounds, (and I’m utterly embarrassed to admit this) I have a feeling that a power far larger than me is helping me write all this.Especially the this:
2. The second cultural distortion: we assumes that if we don’t feel love, there is no love. When it comes to motherly love, this is simply not true.
Repeat after me: just because you can’t feel your love for your child right now, doesn’t mean that you don’t love your child already. All it means is that you have no access to that love.
Hard to believe, right? But at the same time: undeniable. It requires a leap of faith. Faith in the power pf love.
If you are reading this and not feeling it, that’s OK. This magic doesn’t need you to believe in it in order to work. A good analogy is UV radiation: you don’t need to believe in it, you don’t even need to be aware of it to get a sunburn.
So here is the truth:
Your love is pooling inside you, in a secret, magical reservoir. You don’t know about it because it has been cursed by the PPDemons.
They didn’t make your love go away, because they can’t. Love cannot be obliterated. All the PPDemons can do is hide love. They put a curse on your inner spring of love so it can’t flow out, and then put and invisibility spell on the pool that is forming inside .
This means that somewhere, inside you, there is a secret garden. With a fountain. Where your love keeps flowing into a clear pool. You are nourishing everything in the garden, whether you feel it or not.
Your kid, no mater how old, has the key to the garden.
You see, children are immune to invisibility spells.
It’s magic. It works regardless of whether you believe in it or not.
Your baby has access to your love even when you don’t.
Your baby can drink from your fountain, can swim in the pool.
Has been all along.
Someday, (and boy, do I wish I could give you the date) you will heal. Your PPDdemons will lose the the power they hold.
Gradually, trickles of love will find their way out of the secret garden. Fleeting at first, then they will come more often, and will last longer. Until one ordinary day, while doing something as ordinary as changing a diaper, you will find yourself nibbling on his toes, or inhaling the folds of her neck, and you will be struck by that lightning. The floodgate will open.
All the hidden love will wash over you in waves. Your kid, who has been benefiting from it all along, will glow in your happiness. You will bathe in the love, tears and all, until it would be, say, time to start making dinner. But that evening, doing the dishes will be easier. As will be everything else.
So if you are currently suffering form non-bonding fueled depression, please take this on faith: if you want to love your baby, you have the capacity. And it will come. In time. Waiting is the hardest part.
Even then, this feeling of love will ebb and flow.
There will be set-backs. (Dammit!)
Some days you will have trickles, other days gushes.
But your capacity to love your child, yes, even at times you cannot easily access it, is never going away.
You can love.
You are love.
.








A safe haven of Self-Kindness and support. Join me and over 200 moms from around the world at our private facebook group (only members can read and post). You can ask to join on this page:



[...] thing that the three of us have in common is that we love our babies more than we can express. As Yael Saar writes at PPD to Joy, “just because you can’t feel your love for your child right now, doesn’t mean [...]
[...] on twitter) for the sun hiding behind the clouds analogy you offered on my blog post on the absence of love: when not bonding with baby. Much love. 2. Thank you to everybody who has been super supportive of my advocating for my [...]
[...] can be hard to feel, and even harder to believe. Love is magic. It works regardless of whether you can feel it, Regardless of whether you believe in it or [...]
Thank you for this…I am having the hardest time loving my 4 week old. This gives me hope.
Theresa, I am honored that this gives you hope. Much love to you and your baby.
love is powerful! i like how you written your post. that equation is an eye opener. hope everybody knows about it.
april14344 recently posted..Cheapest Insurance for Young Drivers
I’m so happy that these words resonated with you. Thank you for telling me. Hugs.
[...] can be hard to feel, and even harder to believe. Love is magic. It works regardless of whether you can feel it. Regardless of whether you believe in it or [...]
Thank you for writing exactly what I needed to hear. I’m six weeks postpartum and I want to be able to say that motherhood iis the most powerful and amazing experience of my life and that I love my daughter to death. But all I can currently say is that motherhood is not at all what I expected and hoped for and I currently feel like a breastfeeding babysitter. :-( your words give me hope.
THank you for telling me that this is comforting to you. It’s why I do this, and it means a lot to know that it’s working. Much love to you.
This was amazing Yael. I love how you speak to us so gently and reassuringly. My love for my daughter was always there. Maybe a little slow, but it was there. And lately, that love has been overflowing beyond anything I could imagine. I love that girl. So much it makes me cry.
Rach (DonutsMama) recently posted..Actually, I’m Not OK
I know, it’s amazing how love can be powerful enough to make us cry with the sheer joy and scariness of it, isn’t it? I’m so glad you can feel it like this.
Yael, Thank you so much for linking this wonderful very powerfully written post in the Do Good link up. I hope lots of women learn from you and are changed. By the way, would you ever be interested in doing a guest post on my site? I’d LOVE it. Thank you for all of your support. xoxo
Cristi Comes recently posted..GIVEAWAY Last Day to Enter for @Bumbleride Flyer Stroller 359RV Ends Tonight 11-59pm PT
By the way, the gift of love was never a problem for me personally but i do have friends who lived through not “feeling” the love for many months. Its heartbreaking.
Cristi Comes recently posted..GIVEAWAY Last Day to Enter for @Bumbleride Flyer Stroller 359RV Ends Tonight 11-59pm PT
Love your #dogoodlinkup. what a great idea. And I would love writing a guest post for you. I would love collaborating with you on many levels, especially around suicide prevention. Did you know I used to volunteer at the helpline before I started the ppd work? So yes. and love back at you,
yael.
Your ability to see this and to analyze it and then to express it so beautifully astounds me. The feeling of love was never an issue for me, so I can only imagine how horrible that must be. I hope lots of PPD mamas get to read this.
MamaRobinJ recently posted..Master of The Zone
i am so inspired and amazed by your writing, and your transparency is stunningly beautiful. Thank you for pouring your heart out about the hardest things. I will be highlighting this in my awesome reads list next saturday, and promoting the heck out of it. Please consider publishing it at bandbacktogether.com too… would love to see this reach their audience too.
Love to you, Yael. I am so glad to be your friend.
Frelle recently posted..Chick Fight
Yes! Me too!
I will certainly look into bandbacktogether.com
it’s time i started sharing on other venues. thanks for the suggestion.
Love you!
Oh how I cried tears of understanding! I did not get that lightening bolt of love at birth – although I fully expected it.
After a few months and being sent to a counsellor, she gave me some much needed comforting words ” you DO love your baby, the feelings are just not accessible. Like the sun being hidden by the clouds. You may not feel the sun or even see it, but it is always there. ” Those words relieved me of a huge amount of guilt. I’m sure this blog will do the same for other ppd mamas.
Thank you so much for writing this.
Oh Tony, I’m so happy this provided you with some comfort. My heart goes out to you.
That was one smart counselor, I love her analogy, it’s even better than the UV ray ones.
Thank you for your confidence that my work will help others, it’s what keeps me going.
Powerfully written. U did an amazing job!!
Thank you sweet one. Means so much to me.